Salem County, New Jersey — c. 1690

A forgotten crime. A silenced defense. A story finally told.

In the late seventeenth century, along the marshes and farms of colonial New Jersey, a violent crime shattered the fragile order of a young society — and two voices were never allowed to answer for it.

5.0 rating

Cover of Hagar, Young Ben, and the Sheriff: Murder and Justice in Colonial New Jersey by John Pizarro

The Story

At the center of the case were Hagar, an enslaved woman, and Young Ben, a child born into a world that offered little protection and less justice. Accused within a system that denied them a meaningful voice, their story survives only in the brief and often unforgiving language of colonial court records.

But what if they had been given the chance to speak?

Drawing from those records, Hagar, Young Ben and the Sheriff reconstructs this little-known case — exploring not only what happened, but what might have been said in their defense. Set against the stark landscape of Salem County, this narrative brings readers into a world of power, silence, and the uneasy beginnings of law and justice in early America.

From the Pages

“The record gave them a name, a charge, and a sentence. It did not give them a voice. This is what they might have said.”

John Pizarro

Portrait of author John Pizarro outdoors among autumn foliage

About the Author

John Pizarro

John Pizarro is a lifelong New Jersey resident, retired judicial administrator, and amateur historian whose writing explores the intersections of history, justice, and the human experience. He retired after a distinguished 39-year career with the New Jersey Judiciary, where he served as Chief of Probation, gaining firsthand insight into the ways law, institutions, and individual lives intersect. Earlier, he served in the United States Coast Guard, an experience that further shaped his lifelong commitment to public service.

A graduate of Rowan University, Pizarro also holds a master's degree from Fordham University. His enduring fascination with New Jersey's rich and often overlooked past inspired Hagar, Young Ben and the Sheriff, a historical novel based on a little-known seventeenth-century colonial court case. Through extensive research into colonial records and early New Jersey history, he sought to illuminate voices too often absent from the historical record and to explore enduring questions of justice, inequality, and historical memory.

His first book, Carmine Filippone: Not Bad for the Son of an Immigrant, reflects his longstanding interest in preserving overlooked personal and historical narratives. A passionate student of history, Pizarro continues to research and write about overlooked stories from the past. He lives in New Jersey, where he enjoys spending time with family and following football.

An Amazon Best-Selling New Release in Colonial U.S. History

5.0 out of 5

Early praise for Hagar, Young Ben, and the Sheriff

A haunting reconstruction that lingers long after the final page. Pizarro restores dignity to lives the record tried to erase.
Verified Reader
Meticulously researched and deeply humane. It reads like a court transcript reimagined with a conscience.
Verified Reader
Quietly devastating. A vital look at the roots of American justice — and injustice.
Verified Reader

Get in Touch

Contact the Author

Questions, reflections, or an invitation to speak? Send John a note and he'll get back to you.